In Reply to: One more thing... posted by Montyna on July 18, 2005 at 16:35:40:
fact that he was sleeping in the portrait made me wonder as well. Also, a phoenix's tears can heal pretty much anything. Who's to say that Fawkes didn't take care of DD before the others found him and it's all a rouse.
Also, during the funeral they saw what appeared to be a phoenix rising in the flames. Could've been Fawkes, but I wondered if perhaps the phoenix was DD himself and that he would come back to life by the power of the phoenix or something similar. I just have a hard time swallowing that DD would be gone for good. The more I think about it (now this tells you how good of a book this is that we're sitting here talking about this! LOL), the more I think it was a rouse (am I spelling that right?) to help Snape get deeper in w/Voldemort and the Death Eaters.
Post a Followup